Bordeaux Wine Classifications: Why 1855 Endures and Saint-Émilion Has Revised Its Rankings Since 1955
A château classified in 1855 still holds its historic rank. In Saint-Émilion, an estate can become a Grand Cru Classé, be promoted to Premier Grand Cru Classé or lose its title when the ranking is revised. Two Bordeaux wine regions have developed very different ways of recognising their finest wines.
One preserves a reputation inherited from the nineteenth century. The other aims to reward quality as it evolves.
Both approaches raise the same questions: how is reputation built, who decides what an estate is worth, and what room is left for newcomers? Should a classification honour an estate’s history or recognise its current performance? Academic research and accounts from people in the trade reveal paradoxes in both systems.
1855: How a Snapshot of the Wine Trade Became a Historical Benchmark
In 1855, Napoleon III was preparing the Paris Universal Exhibition. The Bordeaux Chamber of Commerce asked the wine brokers’ association to draw up a list of the leading wines of the Gironde. On 18 April 1855, the brokers submitted a ranking in five tiers for the reds and a separate classification for the sweet wines of Sauternes and Barsac.

The classification was drawn up without a large comparative tasting. It was based primarily on selling prices and reputations established through trade in the preceding decades. Lafite, Latour, Margaux and Haut-Brion were already exceptionally prestigious. The list consisted mainly of Médoc estates. Haut-Brion was the geographical exception among the reds, and Saint-Émilion, Pomerol and Fronsac were absent.

The brokers made no claim to have drawn up a ranking for all time. Their task was to represent the market as they knew it. Yet a commercial ranking drawn up for the Universal Exhibition gradually became a landmark of Bordeaux’s heritage.
A rank earned under particular economic conditions thus became a mark of prestige handed down through generations, as the wines and estates continued to change.
The 1855 Classification: A Remarkably Stable Ranking
The ranking has changed very little. Château Cantemerle was added as a fifth growth a few months after the list was drawn up. Mouton Rothschild was promoted from second to first growth in 1973 after a long campaign led by Baron Philippe de Rothschild.
Beyond those changes, there is no mechanism for a ten-year review of the ranks. A classified estate retains its status through changes of ownership, methods and results.
The Médoc châteaux continue to develop. Many invest in viticulture, winemaking and cellar facilities. Prices and critics’ assessments also vary considerably among estates in the same tier.
The Médoc continues to evolve within the fixed official hierarchy of 1855. Its stability gives the classification a clear identity around the world. It can also preserve ranks that no longer match assessments of the estates’ current performance.
1955: Saint-Émilion Chooses to Review Its Rankings
A century after 1855, wine professionals in Saint-Émilion introduced a classification of their own, building on a long tradition of collective organisation. The first classification, established in 1955, recognised 75 estates across the Premiers Grands Crus Classés and Grands Crus Classés categories.

The thinking was different: the ranking would be reviewed periodically, in principle every ten years. Reviews took place in 1969, 1986, 1996, 2006, 2012 and 2022, at intervals that did not always follow the intended schedule.
“Saint-Émilion Grand Cru” is an appellation of controlled origin. “Grand Cru Classé” and “Premier Grand Cru Classé” are distinctions awarded to particular estates.
This principle creates an opportunity unavailable under the 1855 system: an unclassified estate can earn a place through its performance, while an estate already recognised can be demoted or leave the list.
Recognition thus becomes an honour estates can work towards as well as one that can reflect their historical standing.
The Chance of Promotion Encourages Estates to Improve
Jean-Luc Thunevin and Château Valandraud illustrate that opportunity. Established in the 1990s, Valandraud became one of the best-known “garage wines”, combining small volumes, high ambitions for quality and quick recognition from critics. In 2012, the estate was promoted to Premier Grand Cru Classé B.
In an interview with Terre de Vins, Thunevin welcomed the development as “a reward for new blood”. The phrase captures the idea that an estate outside the historic elite can earn a place through its work, investment and reputation.
Château-Figeac followed a different course. A Premier Grand Cru Classé since 1955, it reached Premier Grand Cru Classé A in 2022. Its promotion reflects a long history, a distinctive terroir and investment over several generations.
The prospect of promotion gives estates something to work towards. It can encourage them to improve their vineyards, facilities or the consistency of their wines. Growers’ efforts to express their terroir and compete internationally also drive these improvements.
Researchers Examine What Classifications Really Measure
In Le marché des réputations, the sociologist Pierre-Marie Chauvin shows that the reputation of the great growths also depends on the institutions and people who build it. Classifications do more than capture the state of wine quality at a given moment. By giving some estates lasting recognition, they help create the very hierarchies they present.
Economists offer another perspective. In 2011, Gary Thompson and Stephen Mutkoski published a reassessment of the 1855 classification in the Journal of Wine Economics, drawing on more than 3,100 critics’ scores for vintages from 1970 to 2005. Their model suggested that more than half of the 61 estates studied would change tier if the ranking were rebuilt using those scores.
The result depends on the tasters and statistical methods used, and their scores offer one way to assess quality. The study nevertheless shows how far a historical ranking can diverge from a contemporary assessment.
A 2013 study by Victor Ginsburgh, Muriel Monzak and Andras Monzak highlights the classification’s continuing economic influence. In their analysis of Médoc prices, including the 1855 rank gave their model considerably more explanatory power, although they could not fully separate reputation from quality.
A classification can be disputed as a measure of current performance and still be a powerful marker of value. As well as measuring prestige, it helps sustain it.
Saint-Émilion: The Drawbacks of a Revisable Classification
A system that allows estates to be promoted also allows them to lose rank. A distinction has considerable commercial and symbolic value, and the prospect of losing it can turn the drive to improve into conflict.
The 2006 classification was challenged in court and annulled, after which transitional measures were introduced. In a 2013 study, Julien Cusin, Élodie Loubaresse and Sandra Charreire Petit analysed the crisis through the concept of “coopetition”.
Saint-Émilion estates have a shared interest in protecting the reputation of their appellation. They also compete for its most prestigious positions. They must work together to promote Saint-Émilion while accepting that their estates will be compared.
When the rules or the independence of those doing the assessment are challenged, that tension undermines collective trust. The classification becomes a prize and a focus of the competition itself.
2022: When Leading Estates Chose to Withdraw
Preparations for the 2022 classification exposed new divisions. Cheval Blanc and Ausone, both longstanding Premiers Grands Crus Classés A, announced that they would not apply. Angélus, promoted to the top tier in 2012, and La Gaffelière also withdrew.
Their reasons differed. Several estates criticised the weight given to reputation or commercial visibility relative to the wine, its terroir and its quality. Angélus acknowledged that the classification had originally encouraged estates to improve and criticised the disputes that had accompanied successive reviews.
The paradox is striking: some of Saint-Émilion’s best-known estates believe they can retain their prestige without taking part in the classification. Their absence reflects the decision to withdraw from the process.
In the 2022 process, tasting accounted for 50% of the score, with ten vintages assessed for Grand Cru Classé candidates and fifteen for those seeking Premier Grand Cru Classé. The other criteria covered factors including reputation, vineyard land and how the estate was run.
The process recognised 85 estates: 71 Grands Crus Classés, 12 Premiers Grands Crus Classés B and two Premiers Grands Crus Classés A, Pavie and Figeac.
The system continues to attract candidates, but the withdrawals raise a question: can a classification retain its full authority when some of its biggest names choose to do without it?

The Médoc Also Has Classifications That Can Be Revised
The Médoc is sometimes cast as conservative and Saint-Émilion as dynamic, but that leaves much of the picture out. The 1855 classification covers only part of the Médoc’s wine estates.
The Crus Bourgeois du Médoc have a classification of their own that is regularly updated. The edition published in 2025 recognises 170 estates, in the Crus Bourgeois, Crus Bourgeois Supérieurs and Crus Bourgeois Exceptionnels tiers, for the 2023 to 2027 vintages.

This classification, too, gives estates a chance to earn recognition and move up. The fixed 1855 ranking is only one part of how the Médoc works.
Wine lovers and buyers have other points of reference, including tastings, price trends, recent reputations and consistency across vintages. Historic rank remains influential alongside these other indicators of quality.
Pomerol and Fronsac: Prestige Beyond the Classifications
The history of Pomerol offers a third model. The appellation has no official classification of its estates, yet Pétrus and Le Pin are among the world’s most sought-after wines.
Their reputation rests on terroir, perceived quality, scarcity, the work of the estates and commercial networks. Pomerol shows that estates can build an international reputation without a classification.
In Fronsac, the story is different but just as revealing. Its once-celebrated wines lost some of their commercial standing as other areas of the Libournais rose to prominence. Tastes and markets reshape hierarchies regardless of whether they appear on an official list.
These examples help distinguish three ideas that are often confused: the quality of the wine, the estate’s reputation and the status awarded by a classification. They can reinforce one another, although they do not always coincide.
Conclusion: Should a Classification Honour History or Reflect Quality Today?
The 1855 classification has a rare strength: its stability has made it a global reference. That continuity can also protect historic ranks without regular reassessment.
The Saint-Émilion classification, established in 1955, gives new estates a chance to gain recognition and classified estates a chance to move up. That openness encourages ambition, while exposing the appellation to disputes that can be damaging.
Academic research sheds light on the same paradox: reputation reflects quality and is also shaped by the institutions that recognise it. It draws on performance, history, prices and institutional recognition.
And Pomerol reminds us that a great wine can become famous without a classification.
Should a classification preserve the memory of a wine region, recognise the finest wines of today or give tomorrow’s estates a chance? With its competing models, Bordeaux has never quite settled the question.
Historical and Academic Sources
1. Council of Grands Crus Classés in 1855 – History of the Classification — How the trade ranking was drawn up, the role of the brokers and changes to the original list.
2. Saint-Émilion Wine Council – Saint-Émilion Wine Classification — The origins of the Saint-Émilion classification and how it works.
3. Pierre-Marie Chauvin – Le marché des réputations (2009) — Doctoral thesis in sociology on how the reputations of Bordeaux’s great growths are made.
4. Gary M. Thompson and Stephen A. Mutkoski – Reconsidering the 1855 Bordeaux Classification (2011) — Journal of Wine Economics, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 15–36. A statistical reassessment of the 1855 classification based on tasting scores.
5. Victor Ginsburgh, Muriel Monzak and Andras Monzak – Red Wines of Médoc: What is Wine Tasting Worth? (2013) — Journal of Wine Economics. An analysis of the relationship between reputation, classification and wine prices.
6. Julien Cusin, Élodie Loubaresse and Sandra Charreire Petit – Analyse d’une dynamique de coopétition conflictuelle (2013) — Revue internationale P.M.E., vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 103–125. A study of the crisis surrounding the 2006 Saint-Émilion classification.
7. Terre de Vins – Jean-Luc Thunevin, du garage aux étoiles (2012) — Interview about Valandraud’s promotion and the drive to improve in Saint-Émilion.
8. Château Angélus – Statement on the 2022 Classification — The estate’s official statement on its withdrawal from the process.
9. Château-Figeac – Premier Grand Cru Classé A in 2022 — The estate’s announcement of its promotion.
10. Crus Bourgeois du Médoc – 2025 Classification — Information on the revisable Crus Bourgeois classification.




Comments