Pomerol: An Appellation Facing Climate Change
In Pomerol, one of Bordeaux’s most prestigious winegrowing areas, climate change raises a fundamental question: how can the identity of a great terroir be preserved when the conditions in which vines are grown are changing ever more rapidly?

Heatwaves, repeated droughts and shifting harvest dates are forcing winegrowers to rethink some of their practices. Yet within an appellation d’origine contrôlée (AOC), decisions are not solely a matter for individual estates: they must also comply with a collective set of production rules designed to protect the wines’ origin and distinctive character.
In August 2025, the decision by Château Lafleur to leave the Pomerol AOC and market its wines as Vin de France gave this debate a particularly concrete dimension. It prompts questions about how appellations work and their ability to evolve in response to climate change.
Pomerol’s production rules: protecting a terroir and its wines
An appellation d’origine contrôlée rests on a fundamental principle: a wine’s character is linked to its territory, its natural conditions and the expertise developed there. The appellation’s production specifications translate this relationship into precise rules governing vineyard management, harvesting, winemaking and ageing.
In Pomerol, the basic yield is set at 49 hectolitres per hectare, with a minimum planting density of 5,500 vines per hectare. Wines must be aged at least until 1 November of the year following the harvest. These provisions regulate production while leaving winegrowers a degree of freedom in their technical choices.
The appellation permits Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec and Petit Verdot, among other authorised varieties. Merlot, by far the dominant grape, plays a central role in the identity of Pomerol’s wines. Its early ripening is also a subject of debate as increasingly hot summers can accelerate sugar accumulation and alter the balance between technological ripeness, acidity and phenolic ripeness.
Climate change therefore affects more than harvest dates: it can call into question the balance on which the wines’ historical style is based.
To discover the appellation’s origins and how it built its reputation, read our article: How Did Pomerol Become One of the World’s Most Prestigious Wine Regions?
Protecting the soil: an increasingly important priority
Pomerol’s production specifications pay particular attention to soil preservation. They prohibit, in particular, bringing in soil from outside the delimited vineyard area, as well as substantial changes to the land’s contours and natural soil structure, subject to the exceptions provided for in the rules.
Another important feature is that, since the regulatory changes introduced in 2021, chemical weed control has been prohibited within the appellation. Vegetation must be managed by mechanical or physical means. This measure does not mean that every vineyard in Pomerol is farmed organically, but it reflects a collective commitment to changing certain practices.
As the climate warms, soil management is becoming particularly complex. Ground cover can protect the surface from erosion, improve water infiltration and support biological activity. It can also compete with vines for water, especially during dry springs.
Mechanical soil cultivation has advantages and limitations of its own. It controls vegetation without herbicides, but repeated passes can disturb the structure of the topsoil or encourage it to dry out, depending on conditions.
There is therefore no universal solution: practices must be chosen according to the soil, the climate and the vines’ water status.
Hand harvesting: a tradition, but not a requirement
Pomerol is often associated with hand harvesting, particularly at estates seeking to select bunches meticulously. Yet, contrary to a widespread belief, the production specifications approved in 2021 do not require grapes to be harvested exclusively by hand.
The rules require grapes to be harvested at suitable ripeness and in a healthy condition, without prescribing a single harvesting method. In the current climate, choosing the right moment to harvest is becoming increasingly decisive. High temperatures can accelerate ripening and shorten the period during which grapes offer the desired balance of sugars, acidity and phenolic compounds.
Hand harvesting allows bunches to be selected directly in the vineyard and enables successive picking passes. Mechanical harvesting, for its part, offers a speed of operation that can be valuable when a plot must be picked within a very short time.
In both cases, precise harvest timing, effective sorting and temperature control remain essential. Climate change thus heightens the importance of the winegrower’s decisions, rather than consistently favouring one harvesting method.
Irrigation: a major debate for the future of Bordeaux’s vineyards
In Bordeaux, climate change is gradually disrupting the water balance of vineyards. Traditionally grown without regular irrigation, vines face droughts and increasingly high temperatures. While moderate water stress can help concentrate the grapes, a prolonged deficit can halt ripening and weaken vines in the long term.
In Bordeaux’s AOCs, irrigation is prohibited in principle from 1 May until the harvest, unless a regulatory exemption is granted. Watering young plantings that are not yet in production is a separate matter.
The debate extends beyond appellation rules. Can vineyard irrigation be expanded in the Adour-Garonne basin when its water resources are already under growing pressure? Additional abstraction could increase the strain on rivers, groundwater and ecosystems.
Irrigation also raises a question of equality between winegrowers. Installing a drip irrigation system, connecting it and maintaining it represent substantial investments that some businesses can scarcely afford in a Bordeaux wine region already facing a deep economic crisis. The wealthiest estates could therefore gain access to adaptation measures beyond the reach of more vulnerable producers, increasing inequalities in the face of climate change.

Other responses to these environmental and economic challenges can be developed: more drought-tolerant rootstocks, soil preservation, adjustments to ground cover and changes to vineyard management.
The challenge is therefore not only to adapt Bordeaux’s vineyards to climate change, but also to enable a transition that is environmentally sustainable and economically accessible to all winegrowers.
Château Lafleur: why leave the Pomerol appellation in 2025?
On 24 August 2025, the Guinaudeau family announced that the six wines of the Société Civile du Château Lafleur would no longer claim the Pomerol and Bordeaux appellations from the 2025 vintage onwards. They would instead be declared as Vin de France.
The decision was all the more surprising because Château Lafleur ranks among Bordeaux’s most highly regarded estates. It was neither a sanction nor a loss of recognition for quality, but a voluntary choice.
In its official letter entitled “S’offrir le Choix de Choisir” (“Giving Ourselves the Freedom to Choose”), the family explained that rapid climate change required adjustments to the way its vineyards were managed. In its view, appellation rules did not allow these changes to be implemented quickly enough.
Irrigation featured prominently in reactions to the announcement. However, it would be reductive to explain the entire decision in terms of a single practice: Lafleur was making a broader case for the freedom to adapt its viticulture to new climatic constraints.
Leaving the AOC without leaving the terroir
Lafleur’s departure raises a particularly interesting question: what does giving up an appellation mean for an estate whose vines remain rooted in the same territory?
A change of administrative category alters neither the geology of the plots, nor their exposure, nor their plant material. It does, however, change the regulatory framework to which the producer chooses to adhere and the indications of origin that may appear on its labels.
For an estate with an international reputation as strong as Lafleur’s, the property’s name can continue to convey a commercial identity independently of the AOC. The situation differs for many less well-known producers, for whom the appellation provides both a collective guarantee of origin and an essential point of reference in the marketplace.
Lafleur’s decision therefore does not demonstrate that AOCs have outlived their usefulness. Rather, it reveals tensions between producers’ individual choices and collectively established rules.
Can appellations evolve quickly enough?
Production specifications are not set in stone. They have regularly been amended to incorporate new production requirements, technical developments and environmental objectives. Pomerol’s ban on chemical weed control is a concrete example.
Climate change, however, presents a different kind of difficulty. Its effects follow neither a regular timetable nor a uniform progression. From one year to the next, winegrowers may face prolonged droughts, intense rainfall or exceptional heat.

There are many possible responses: adapting cover crops, changing canopy management, choosing rootstocks, adjusting planting densities, selecting plant material and managing water judiciously.
Some measures can be implemented at estate level. Others require changes to collective rules or national regulations.
In June 2026, the INAO announced that it was accelerating several initiatives on the adaptation of appellations, including carefully managed irrigation and changes to production specifications.
The challenge is not simply to set tradition against modernity, but to determine which practices should be preserved and which can evolve without causing wines to lose their identity.
Conclusion: does preserving terroir also mean accepting change?
Pomerol illustrates one of the major challenges facing French viticulture. Appellations were created to protect the origin of wines, regulate their production and preserve collective expertise. Their strength lies precisely in this continuity.
Yet climate change is gradually transforming the natural conditions on which these traditions were built. Soil protection, water management and the adaptation of vineyard practices are consequently becoming increasingly important.
By leaving the Pomerol AOC, Château Lafleur has chosen an individual path that cannot be extended to all producers. Its decision nevertheless invites reflection on the ability of appellations to evolve.
Preserving a terroir’s identity does not necessarily mean retaining every practice inherited from the past. It can also mean adapting those practices so that vines can continue to express that territory in the decades ahead.
Sources and bibliography
INAO and the French Ministry of Agriculture, Pomerol AOC production specifications, approved on 12 October 2021. Reference for yields, soil management, harvesting and irrigation. Read the official document.
Code rural et de la pêche maritime, Article D.645-5, on the conditions governing irrigation in AOC vineyards. Read on Légifrance.
Légifrance
Guinaudeau family, S’offrir le Choix de Choisir, letter dated 24 August 2025 announcing Lafleur’s departure from the appellations. Read the original letter.
INAO, statement following the meetings of 17–18 June 2026 on the adaptation of appellations, carefully managed irrigation and changes to production specifications. Read the statement.
INAO
Code rural et de la pêche maritime, Article D.645-5: the prohibition in principle of irrigation in AOC vineyards from 1 May until the harvest, and the conditions for exemptions. Read the official text.
Légifrance
Agence de l’eau Adour-Garonne, 2025 assessment of the Adour-Garonne basin: pressures on water resources and the consequences of climate change. Read the assessment.
Agence de l’eau Adour-Garonne, Hydrologie et changements climatiques : quelles tendances observées et à venir ? Read the scientific summary.
Agence de l’eau Adour-Garonne




Comments