top of page

DO THE
RIGHT THING
DO THE
RIGHT BANK

Blog

Search

Did Bordeaux’s Vineyards Really Decline After the Fall of Rome? From the 5th to the 12th Century

9 hours ago
13 min read

From the 5th to the 12th century, how did vines weather seven centuries of upheaval before the rise of Bordeaux’s great wine trade?


In the 4th century, the poet Ausonius evoked the vine-covered landscapes of Roman Aquitaine. Nearly nine centuries later, Bordeaux was gradually establishing itself as one of Europe’s great centres of the wine trade. Between these two periods, however, the history of its vineyards seems to disappear from the sources. What happened to Bordeaux’s vines after the fall of the Roman Empire?


Vine leaves and grapes carved on an early Christian sarcophagus at Saint-Seurin in Bordeaux.
Early Christian sarcophagus at Saint-Seurin in Bordeaux (probably 5th century). Preserved in the crypt of Saint-Seurin Basilica in Bordeaux, Gironde, it features vine leaves and bunches of grapes, recalling the importance of the vine in the Bordeaux region since Roman times. Similar motifs decorated mosaics at the Gallo-Roman villa of Le Palat in Saint-Émilion. This artistic continuity illustrates the vine’s place in regional culture, without in itself proving uninterrupted wine production. Photo credit: Moleskine, 2021 — Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 licence. Photograph cropped and retouched for La Closerie de Fronsac.

Visigothic settlement, Frankish rule, Carolingian campaigns and Viking raids profoundly transformed Aquitaine. For a long time, this succession of upheavals sustained an image of centuries of decline, during which vine cultivation supposedly survived chiefly through religious communities. But is this interpretation really borne out by historical documents? Sixth-century accounts attest to vines in the countryside around Bordeaux. In the early 7th century, documents still refer to large rural estates.


Then, from the 11th century onwards, cartularies reveal organised viticulture in several parts of the Bordeaux region, particularly on the Right Bank. Did the vineyards really decline, or does this impression mainly reflect the loss of a large proportion of the archives? Historical research, archaeology and, more recently, the scientific study of grape seeds now allow us to reconsider this period, long described as obscure.


1. After Rome: the disappearance of an economic system, but not necessarily of the vine


Winegrowing in Roman Bordeaux formed part of an economy organised around large agricultural estates, transport routes and commercial networks linking the Empire’s different provinces. Archaeological research, particularly the work of Pierre Sillières and the collective synthesis published in the journal Gallia in 2001, has helped to document the origins and development of this activity in Aquitaine.


From the 5th century onwards, the western Roman world underwent profound changes. Imperial power gradually gave way to new authorities. Bordeaux came under Visigothic rule, then Frankish control after the Battle of Vouillé in 507. Political change, however, does not mean that the countryside was abandoned. Land continued to be cultivated, populations needed food supplies, and large estates sometimes retained part of their economic role. The disappearance of imperial administration therefore does not automatically imply the disappearance of the crops developed under Roman rule.


We nevertheless know very little about how the area under vines changed. Did trade diminish? Did some estates abandon their vineyards? Did others continue producing for local markets? The surviving documents cannot provide precise answers to these questions. The first difficulty is therefore methodological: we must distinguish between the disappearance of historical evidence and the disappearance of winegrowing itself.


2. In the 6th century, Venantius Fortunatus still described vineyards around Bordeaux


One of the period’s most important accounts comes from the poet Venantius Fortunatus, who lived in Gaul during the second half of the 6th century. Among those he knew was Leontius II, Bishop of Bordeaux, a powerful figure, prolific builder and owner of rural estates. In his Poems, Fortunatus describes a property called Praemiacum, traditionally identified with Preignac in the Garonne valley. The poem evokes several components of its agricultural landscape, including meadows, cultivated land and vines. Nearly a century after the disappearance of the Western Roman Empire, winegrowing was therefore still present in the Bordeaux countryside.


Venantius Fortunatus’s cross-shaped poem in a 9th-century Carolingian manuscript copy.
De signaculo sanctae crucis (‘On the Sign of the Holy Cross’), a figured poem (carmen figuratum) composed in the 6th century by Venantius Fortunatus, Bishop of Poitiers and a contemporary of Leontius II, in which the Latin text forms a cross. — Carolingian copy from the 9th century (c. 833–866). Source: St. Gallen, Stiftsbibliothek, Cod. Sang. 196, p. 40 (www.e-codices.ch).

This account also reveals the persistence of certain forms of landownership inherited from Late Antiquity. Leontius was a religious dignitary, but he also belonged to a landowning elite whose estates were sources of income and prestige. The text must nevertheless be interpreted cautiously. In a study published in 2026, the historian Gaëlle Herbert de la Portbarré-Viard examines precisely how Venantius Fortunatus constructs his descriptions of landscapes and architecture. His poems are not straightforward agricultural observations: they construct literary images intended to celebrate their recipients.


The account of Praemiacum is therefore valuable, but tells us neither the area under cultivation, nor the quantities produced, nor the wine’s commercial destinations. It attests to the existence of vines without allowing us to measure the extent of the vineyards. This distinction is essential to understanding the limitations of early medieval sources.


3. Plassac and Floirac: the persistence of large estates in the 7th century


Another document complements Fortunatus’s account: the will of Bertechramnus, Bishop of Le Mans, drawn up in 615–616. He owned several properties in the Bordeaux region, notably at Plassac, near the Gironde estuary, and at Floirac, on the right bank of the Garonne. These references are particularly interesting because they demonstrate the persistence of substantial landed wealth in Merovingian Aquitaine.


At Plassac, archaeological excavations have also uncovered the remains of a remarkable Gallo-Roman villa, occupied and transformed over several centuries. It would nevertheless be unwise to equate every phase of this villa unreservedly with the properties described in the will. Research into ancient viticulture in Aquitaine uses these documents, alongside Fortunatus’s account, to examine the persistence of vine cultivation around Bordeaux in the 6th and 7th centuries.


Gallo-Roman mosaic with overlapping scale motifs at the villa of Plassac, c. AD 390–430.
Gallo-Roman mosaic at the villa of Plassac (c. AD 390–430), Gironde. This polychrome pavement with overlapping scale motifs illustrates the refinement of the Bordeaux region’s great aristocratic estates towards the end of the Roman Empire. Situated on the banks of the Gironde estuary, the villa of Plassac demonstrates the wealth of ancient rural estates, some of which survived in new forms during the Merovingian period. Photo credit: Franck-fnba, 2025 — Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 licence. Image retouched (brightness, contrast and colours).

These texts do not prove that Roman vineyards retained their extent or their practices, but they contradict the idea that winegrowing disappeared altogether. The rural economy was clearly undergoing change. Certain forms of landownership endured, while their organisation and those who worked the land could change. The history of the vineyards must be placed within this broader transformation of the countryside.


4. Did monks really save winegrowing?


The idea that monks preserved vines after the invasions is deeply rooted in wine history. Religious institutions certainly played an important role. Wine was needed to celebrate the Eucharist. It was also used in everyday nourishment, hospitality and economic exchange. Bishops, abbeys and religious chapters therefore owned vineyard land whose income helped to support their activities.


Yet their role must not obscure that of other participants. The historian Roger Dion had already highlighted the importance of winegrowing by princes and great landowners. Medieval research also shows that ecclesiastical land formed part of much more complex networks of property and social relationships. Religious institutions received donations of land that was sometimes already cultivated. They acquired properties, collected dues and organised their exploitation. Owning a vineyard does not necessarily mean cultivating it oneself.


Behind episcopal and monastic estates worked peasants, tenants and rural families who are rarely named in the sources. They carried out pruning, maintained plots and harvested the grapes. The continuity of winegrowing therefore also depended on the transmission of practical knowledge within farming communities, even though this process is particularly difficult to document. Monks were not the vine’s only guardians: above all, they left records that make their role much more visible than that of the cultivators.


5. From the 7th to the 10th century: four almost silent centuries


Between the last Merovingian accounts and the proliferation of cartularies in the late 11th century, documents directly concerned with Bordeaux winegrowing are extremely scarce. The region’s history is then known chiefly through political and religious chronicles. In 769, the Royal Frankish Annals report that Charlemagne had a fortress built at Fronsac, on the Dordogne, during his campaign against Hunald of Aquitaine. The event confirms the territory’s strategic importance without providing direct evidence of winegrowing on the surrounding slopes.


In the 9th century, Viking raids brought a new source of instability. The Annals of Saint-Bertin record, in particular, the capture of Bordeaux in 848. These attacks may have disrupted trade and farming. Yet we have no data with which to measure their impact on the area under vines in the Bordeaux region. Frédéric Boutoulle’s research on the Vikings in Bordeaux also shows how later accounts helped to amplify or reshape the memory of these events. We must therefore avoid treating invasions as an automatic explanation for prolonged viticultural decline.


The scarcity of sources is itself part of the problem. Surviving documents primarily served political, religious or legal purposes. They rarely mention ordinary agricultural activities. The absence of references to vines does not necessarily mean that they were no longer cultivated. Conversely, we cannot claim that winegrowing continued everywhere without contraction or change. This period remains one of the greatest areas of uncertainty in the history of Bordeaux’s vineyards.


6. From the 11th century onwards, archives reveal an organised vineyard landscape


A considerable change occurred in the final decades of the 11th century. Religious institutions produced and preserved more documents concerning donations, sales, land rights and dues. These records, gradually gathered into cartularies, allow part of the rural economy to be reconstructed.


In a study published in 2000 in the Annales du Midi, the historian Frédéric Boutoulle examines winegrowing in the Bordeaux and Bazas regions between the late 11th and early 13th centuries. He identifies 326 documents mentioning vines between 1070 and 1225, representing 17.4% of the documentary corpus studied. These figures do not constitute a census of winegrowing holdings. Several documents may concern the same land, while other plots never appear in the archives. They nevertheless show that vines occupied a significant place in transactions and income from land.


Synthesis map of references to Bordeaux-region vineyards in medieval cartularies, 1070–1225.
The main winegrowing areas of the Bordeaux region mentioned in cartularies between 1070 and 1225. Medieval records attest to vineyards around Bordeaux, in the Entre-deux-Mers and in several Right Bank territories, particularly the Fronsadais and Saint-Émilion. These documentary references do not, however, allow the exact extent of vineyards at that time to be reconstructed. Original synthesis map — La Closerie de Fronsac. Based on the research of Charles Higounet (1978) and Frédéric Boutoulle (2000).

Vineyards were sold, donated, passed on or worked under various agreements between owners and cultivators. In the late 11th century, Bordeaux’s vineyards therefore did not suddenly reappear: they became much better documented. The records reveal agriculture already integrated into the social and economic organisation of the countryside.


7. Where were Bordeaux’s vineyards before the great English wine trade?


This is probably the most interesting contribution of the research undertaken by Charles Higounet, followed by Frédéric Boutoulle. By examining the locations of plots mentioned in cartularies, historians began reconstructing the geography of medieval winegrowing. Unlike today’s image of a vast, continuous vineyard landscape, vines then appear to have been distributed among several distinct areas.


Around Bordeaux, they were present in urban and suburban spaces, notably on the gravelly ground of the Left Bank. Other vineyards occupied the slopes of the right bank of the Garonne, as well as those of the Bourg and Blaye areas. By the 12th century, documents also attest to the development of winegrowing in the Entre-deux-Mers. These observations suggest viticulture serving a combination of local needs, rural estates and trade whose importance varied from one territory to another.


Saint-Émilion, Montagne and the Fronsadais already appear in the archives


Boutoulle’s study sheds particularly valuable light on the Right Bank. It shows that La Sauve-Majeure Abbey owned vineyards at Saint-Émilion, Montagne and in the Fronsadais. Other religious institutions provide additional information. The cartulary of the Hospitaller commanderies of Lalande and Pomerol, covering approximately 1120–1192, mentions, among other things, a vineyard near the settlement of Saint-Émilion around 1120.


These references attest to winegrowing holdings in territories now associated with major Bordeaux appellations, long before their modern recognition. They do not, however, allow us to draw the boundaries of these vineyards or equate them with today’s appellations.


Another difficulty stems from the loss of documents. Boutoulle points out that several important religious institutions in the Libourne, Fronsac, Bourg and Blaye areas left few or no archives. Our geographical knowledge of winegrowing is therefore uneven. A region frequently mentioned in cartularies was not necessarily more extensively planted with vines than another: it was sometimes simply better documented. This observation reinforces our original question: the history of vineyards also depends on the geography of archival survival.


Romanesque portal of Saint-Georges church in Montagne, near Saint-Émilion.
Romanesque portal of Saint-Georges church in Montagne (late 11th–early 12th century), in the Saint-Émilion wine region, Gironde. This church is one of the rare surviving examples of early Romanesque architecture in the Bordeaux wine region, retaining remarkable architectural integrity despite several restorations. Documented from 1110, it illustrates the growth of religious institutions at a time when winegrowing was expanding in the Libourne area. Photo credit: William Ellison — Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Photograph cropped and perspective corrected.

8. La Sauve-Majeure Abbey: a major participant in medieval winegrowing


Founded in 1079 by Gérard de Corbie, La Sauve-Majeure Abbey gradually became one of Aquitaine’s great religious institutions. Established in the Entre-deux-Mers, it built up extensive landed holdings over the decades through donations, acquisitions and various rights. Its Grand cartulaire, published in 1996 by Charles Higounet and Arlette Higounet-Nadal, is a fundamental source for the region’s rural history. Its records allow the place of vines within the abbey’s possessions to be examined.


They also reveal a society far more complex than the traditional image of monks single-handedly clearing abandoned land. In her research into the aristocracy of the Entre-deux-Mers, Françoise Bériac demonstrated the importance of lay families in the formation of monastic holdings. Land donated to the abbey previously belonged to owners whose interests could be religious, familial, political or economic. Boutoulle’s work on rural settlement in the Bordeaux region, for its part, highlights the diversity of farming units and landholding relationships.


Monasteries therefore did not simply create new vineyards: they also acquired, developed and organised holdings that may have existed before them. Their role was nevertheless essential in structuring certain properties and preserving the documents through which they can be studied today. La Sauve-Majeure Abbey thus provides major evidence of rural expansion in the 11th and 12th centuries, when the region’s vineyards were entering a better-documented phase of transformation.


9. Did the English trade create Bordeaux’s vineyards?


In 1152, the marriage of Eleanor of Aquitaine to Henry Plantagenet, the future King of England, opened a new period in the region’s political and economic history. Trade with the Plantagenet territories gradually assumed considerable importance. This event is often presented as the starting point of Bordeaux’s wine prosperity. Land records show, however, that the vineyards already existed and were developing before 1152.


The research of Higounet and Boutoulle shows that the expansion of cultivated land and the transformation of economic relationships formed part of a longer process. The English trade was therefore not an absolute beginning, but a powerful accelerator.


Moreover, Bordeaux did not immediately become the main port exporting wine to England. In the late 12th century, La Rochelle still held a major position in the Atlantic trade in wines from Aunis and Saintonge. Its transfer to Capetian control in 1224 subsequently helped to strengthen Bordeaux’s commercial prospects within an expansion already under way.


The increasingly export-oriented vineyards of the 13th century did not emerge overnight. They were the result of several generations of agricultural, landholding and commercial changes that began long before Eleanor’s marriage. This gradual development prepared the way for one of the great chapters in the history of Bordeaux wine.


To discover how English rule transformed the wine trade, encouraged the rise of claret and led to the establishment of Bordeaux’s famous wine privilege, read our article: Bordeaux Under the Plantagenets: Claret, Vineyards and the Privilege of Wine.


10. What recent scientific research can tell us


Historians no longer rely solely on medieval texts to study the development of winegrowing. Advances in archaeobotany and genetics now make it possible to examine certain plant remains preserved on archaeological sites directly.


In 2024, a research team led by Laurent Bouby published a study in Scientific Reports covering 19,377 archaeological grape seeds found in France. By analysing their shapes and dimensions, the scientists examined the evolution of grapevine populations and changes associated with their domestication over thousands of years.


A new study published in March 2026 in Nature Communications took a further step by analysing ancient DNA from 49 archaeological grape seeds, mainly from France, spanning around four thousand years. Its findings document the genetic diversity of ancient vines and relationships between certain historical lineages and modern varieties. These studies open remarkable perspectives for understanding the movement of grape varieties and the transmission of plant material.


Yet they do not directly demonstrate the continuity of Bordeaux’s vineyards between the 5th and 12th centuries. Establishing such continuity locally would require well-dated plant remains from sufficiently numerous and representative archaeological contexts in the Bordeaux region.


This is one of the interests of the Paléo-Pépins project, supported by the University of Bordeaux in 2025, which brings together several disciplines to help trace the history of the region’s grape varieties. New scientific methods may eventually make it possible to compare written accounts with the biological history of the vines themselves. Above all, they remind us that wine history remains a living field of research, in which new discoveries can change interpretations long regarded as established.


Conclusion: did Bordeaux’s vineyards really experience seven centuries of decline?


Between the end of the Roman Empire and the 12th century, the history of Bordeaux winegrowing remains fragmentary. The accounts of Venantius Fortunatus in the 6th century, the land records of the early 7th century and the numerous documents from the 11th and 12th centuries nevertheless show that vine cultivation did not disappear from the region. What we cannot measure is the scale of production and its possible fluctuations during the least-documented centuries.


Invasions and political changes certainly affected the rural economy, but they are not enough to demonstrate a general, prolonged collapse of winegrowing. From the late 11th century, cartularies reveal vineyards that were already organised, notably around Bordeaux, in the Entre-deux-Mers, at Saint-Émilion and in the Fronsadais.


Rather than disappearance followed by rebirth, the evidence suggests agricultural continuities, reorganisations of landownership and developments whose pace remains difficult to measure. The question is therefore not only how vines survived Rome, but how they adapted to a profoundly different medieval society.


When Bordeaux became a great centre of the wine trade in the 13th century, its vineyards did not arise from nothing. They inherited centuries of transformation, whose full complexity archives and scientific research are only beginning to reveal.


Historical and scientific sources


Ancient sources and medieval accounts



Historical studies



Archaeology and grapevine genetics


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page